22 March 2022

If I Had My Way: Each Year's Oscar Winner for Best Picture, My Favorite Nominee of the Nominees and My Favorite Picture

All Quiet on the Western Front, the Academy and I agreed on this one

Below you will find each year's Oscar winner for best picture followed by my favorite of that year's nominees and my favorite film for that year. You will note that in a few cases for best nominee I put N/A (not applicable) because in my estimation, there wasn't anything nominated worthy of the prize. In only eight years did the Oscar winner match what I thought was the best movie (All Quiet on the Western From '30, Casablanca '42, On the Waterfront '54, The Godfather '72, Annie Hall '77, No Country for Old Men '07 and Birdman '14). On sixteen occasions the best picture was, in my opinion, the best of the nominees. Sixty-five times my favorite film of the year did not receive a nomination (although many were foreign language films and some of those were nominated in that category.). Please excuse my failure to link the films to IMDb as I normally do, but with over two hundred titles, it's simply too time-consuming a task.

1928 Wings/Wings/Sunrise

1929 Broadway Melody/NA/Diary of a Lost Girl

1930 All Quiet on the Western Front/All Quiet on the Western Front/All Quiet on the Western Front

1931 Cimarron/ The Front Page/City Lights

1932 Grand Hotel/Shanghai Express/Red Dust

1933 Cavalcade/42nd Street/Duck Soup

1934 It Happened One Night/The Thin Man/The Thin Man

1935 Mutiny on the Bounty/Ruggles of Red Gap/The Thirty-Nine Steps

1936 The Great Ziegfeld/Libeled Lady/My Man Godfrey

1937 The Life of Emile Zola/The Awful Truth/The Awful Truth

1938 You Can’t Take it With You/Grand Illusion/Holiday

1939 Gone With the Wind/Mr. Smith Goes to Washington/Mr. Smith Goes to Washington

1940 Rebecca/ The Grapes of Wrath/His Girl Friday

1941 How Green Was My Valley/Citizen Kane/Sullivan’s Travels

1942 Mrs. Miniver/The Talk of the Town/The Talk of the Town

1943 Casablanca/Casablanca/Casablanca

1944 Going My Way/Double Indemnity/Double Indemnity

1945 The Lost Weekend/The Lost Weekend/Rome: Open City

1946 The Best Years of Our Lives/It’s a Wonderful Life/It’s a Wonderful Life

1947 Gentleman’s Agreement/Great Expectations/Odd Man Out

1948 Hamlet/Treasure of the Sierra Madre/Treasure of the Sierra Madre

1949 All the King’s Men/Battleground/The Third Man

1950 All About Eve/Sunset Blvd./Sunset Blvd.

1951 An American in Paris/A Streetcar Named Desire/A Streetcar Named Desire

1952 The Greatest Show on Earth/High Noon/Umberto D

1952 From Here to Eternity/Julius Caesar/Ikiru

1954 On the Waterfront/On the Waterfront/On the Waterfront

1955 Marty/Mister Roberts/Rebel Without a Cause

1956 Around the World in 80 Days/NA/The Searchers

1957 Bridge on the River Kwai/Bridge on the River Kwai/The Seventh Seal

1958 Gigi/The Defiant One/Elevator to the Gallows

1959 Ben-Hur/NA/Some Like it Hot

1960 The Apartment/The Apartment/La Dolce Vita

1961 West Side Story/The Hustler/Through a Glass Darkly

1962 Lawrence of Arabia/To Kill a Mockingbird/L’Eclisse

1963 Tom Jones/NA/Winter Light

1964 My Fair Lady/Dr. Strangelove/Red Desert

1965 The Sound of Music/A Thousand Clowns/I Knew Her Well

1966 A Man for All Seasons/The Sand Pebbles/Persona

1967 In the Heat of the Night/Bonnie and Clyde/Bonnie and Clyde

1968 Oliver/The Lion in Winter/2001: A Space Odyssey

1969 Midnight Cowboy/Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid/The Wild Bunch

1970 Patton/M*A*S*H*/Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion

1971 The French Connection/A Clockwork Orange/A Clockwork Orange

1972 The Godfather/The Godfather/The Godfather

1973 The Sting/The Exorcist/Amacord

1974 Godfather Part 2/ Chinatown/Chinatown

1975 One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest/Barry Lyndon/Barry Lyndon

1976 Rocky/Taxi Driver/Taxi Driver

1977 Annie Hall/Annie Hall/Annie Hall

1978 Deer Hunter/Deer Hunter/Animal House

1979 Kramer vs. Kramer/Apocalypse Now/Manhattan

1980 Ordinary People/Raging Bull/Heaven’s Gate

1981 Chariots of Fire/Reds/Reds

1982 Gandhi/The Verdict/Fanny and Alexander

1983 Terms of Endearment/The Right Stuff/Local Hero

1984 Amadeus/Places in the Heart/Broadway Danny Rose

1985 Out of Africa/Witness/Come and See

1986 Platoon/Platoon/Down by Law

1987 The Last Emperor/NA/Au Revoir Les Enfants

1988 Rain Man/Dangerous Liaisons/Bull Durham

1989 Driving Miss Daisy/My Left Foot/Crimes & Misdemeanors

1990 Dances With Wolves/Goodfellas/Goodfellas

1991 The Silence of the Lambs/JFK/Europa

1992 Unforgiven/The Crying Game/La Vie de boheme

1993 Schindler’s List/Schindler’s List/Groundhog Day

1994 Forrest Gump/Pulp Fiction/Pulp Fiction

1995 Braveheart/Il Postino/Dead Man

1996 The English Patient/Fargo/Drifting Clouds

1997 Titanic/Good Will Hunting/Ice Storm

1998 Shakespeare in Love/Saving Private Ryan/The Big Lebowski

1999 American Beauty/American Beauty/The Virgin Suicides

2000 Gladiator/Traffic/In the Mood For Love

2001 A Beautiful Mind/Gosford Park/Y Tu Mama Tambien

2002 Chicago/Gangs of New York/Hable Con Ella

2003 Lord of the Rings/Lost in Translation/The Man Without a Past

2004 Million Dollar Baby/The Aviator/Mean Girls

2005 Crash/Good Night and Good Luck/Match Point

2006 The Departed/The Departed/Half Nelson

2007 No Country For Old Men/No Country For Old Men/No Country For Old Men

2008 Slumdog Millionaire/Milk/Vicky Cristina Barcelona

2009 The Hurt Locker/Inglourious Basterds/Inglourious Basterds

2010 The King’s Speech/Winter’s Bone/Of Gods and Men

2011 The Artist/Midnight in Paris/Midnight in Paris

2012 Argo/Silver Linings Playbook/Silver Linings Playbook

2013 12 Years a Slave/Nebraska/Inside Llewyn Davis

2014 Birdman/Birdman/Birdman

2015 Spotlight/The Revenant/Carol

2016 Moonlight/Manchester by the Sea/Manchester by the Sea

2017 The Shape of Water/Call Me by Your Name/Personal Shopper

2018 Green Book/Roma/First Reformed

2019 Parasite/Once Upon a Time in Hollywood/Once Upon a Time in Hollywood

2020 Nomadland/Promising Young Woman/Another Round

2021 CODA/Drive My Car/Drive My Car

2022 Everything Everywhere All At Once/Tar/Aftersun

2023 Oppenheimer/Oppenheimer/Fallen Leaves

No comments: