Katharine Hepburn and Cary Grant in Brining Up Baby |
Bringing Up Baby (1938) Hawks and What’s Up, Doc? (1972) Bogdanovich. The first is, of course, one of the great all time screwball comedies and features one of several pairings of Katherine Hepburn and Cary Grant. It's about a daffy dame who --we're not sure why -- falls for a straight-laced, serious and perpetually dead-panned scientist. The story involves a leopard named baby, a dog burying a dinosaur bone and all the requisite madcap antics that comprise a screwball comedy. What's Up is Peter Bogdanovich's modern version with Ryan O'Neal and Barbara Streisand assuming the two lead roles. San Francisco is the setting and its many hills prove vital to the climatic chase scene. O'Neal, like Grant, is scientist and Streisand, like Hepburn a pixelated woman who loves him. Both films include a fiancé for the male lead who in Doc it is Madeline Kahn in her film debut. The main and most important similarity between the two is that they are hilarious.
The Philadelphia Story (1940) Cukor and High Society (1956) Walters. Philadelphia Story also features Hepburn and Grant and throws in Jimmy Stewart for good measure. Our leads are a divorced and Hepburn's Tracy Lord is set to marry a man that anyone can see is ill-suited for her. Grant has been coaxed into showing up at the wedding so that a reporter (Stewart) can get the scoop for a scandal sheet. It's a very funny film but not played solely for laughs as many of the scenes between the two leads show. High Society is a musical version of the story and the only film I here mention that I'm not a huge fan of. Still it is a passable film, as light as air and fun to watch when you consider that Frank Sinatra and Bing Crosby are doing the singing and Louis Armstrong provides instrumentals. Plus Grace Kelly plays Tracy Lord in her final film role before she became the Princess of Monaco (true story).
Casablanca (1942) Curtiz and Play it Again, Sam (1972) Ross. I don't suppose anyone needs a detailed summary of Casablanca so I'll focus on Sam and how it is a nice accompaniment to the Bogie classic. Woody Allen plays a film critic who is obsessed with Bogart (here played admirably, if imperfectly by Jerry Lacy) and has conversations with him. He is best friends with a married couple (Diane Keaton and Tony Roberts) who try to help recover from a recent divorce and find true love. Allen finds love but it is in the person of Keaton's character. There's a very strong Casablanca influenced vibe to the story although with Woody instead of Bogie it is done for laughs. The climatic scene of Sam mirrors Casablanca. One of the great oddities of my film-viewing experience is that I actually saw Sam first. Anyway, watch them in the proper order and enjoy,
Madeline Carroll and Robert Donat in The 39 Steps |
Winter Light (1963) Bergman and First Reformed (2017) Schrader. Some people might have paired First Reformed with Taxi Driver (1976) Scorsese (Paul Schrader wrote the screenplays for both) and indeed they bear striking similarities. However I think it bears more of a resemblance to Winter Light, my favorite Bergman film (which is saying a lot because he's my favorite director). Both center around ministers who are suffering crises of faith. Both are loved by a woman that he is cruel to. Both counsel a parishioner who is suicidal with similar results. There are many divergences in their stories, such as the love found by the minister in First Reformed. But both are very heavy movies that ask one to think about many topics including the big one -- God's silence. You may need to be in the right mood but you'll feel better for having watched them
A Streetcar Named Desire (1951) and Blue Jasmine (2013). This is a pretty obvious pairing. Here we have two excellent films that feature bravura acting performances by actress who won Best Actress Oscars (Vivian Leigh and Cate Blanchett). Both played women who lost their marbles and watching that mental disintegration is a fascinating cinematic experience. There are numerous other similarities in their stories including a sister coming to stay with family in another city after a breakdown. Both women have suitors and in both cases the romances are ill-fated. While both feature strong supporting casts there is no matching Streetcar which includes Marlon Brando but that's to take nothing away from a fine performance in Jasmine by Bobby Cannavale as the testosterone-fueled muscle-bound brother-in-law.
Cristine Miloti and Andy Samberg in Palm Springs |
Here Comes Mr. Jordan (1941) Hall and Heaven Can Wait (1978) Beatty. In Mr. Jordan we have a boxer (Robert Montgomery) nearing a shot at the tile when he is mistakenly taken to heaven after an accident. In Heaven Warren Beatty is an NFL quarterback on the verge of the Super Bowl who is also mistakenly killed off in an accident. In both cases the execs up in heaven have to send the deceased back but need to find a different body and both end up temporarily occupying the form of a multi-millionaire of bad character until an athlete's body becomes available. Both find love along the way. They are funny, romantic, clever and interesting films that include excellent supporting casts. Edward Everett Horton, James Gleason and Claude Rains in the original and Jack Warden, Charles Grodin and James Mason in the latter film. Heaven has the advantage of featuring the scrumptious Julie Christie as the love interest but I still slightly prefer Jordan. Both good films and good fun.
Apocalypse Now (1979) Coppola and Platoon (1986) Stone. Why not go back to the muck and mire and blood and guts of the Vietnam War? Other than the setting they have little in common, oh except for the fact that their fantastic films. Both are unsparing in their look at war. Apocalypse is based on Joseph Conrad's novel, Heart of Darkness and stars Martin Sheen as a man on a US Army sanctioned assignment to kill a man. He'll need to weave through the war and some of its attendant insanity and insane figures to do it. Platoon is roughly a true story (there's nothing fantastic about it) of a young solider and his platoon (hence the title) as it experiences the horrors of war, particularly Vietnam style. There are atrocities, sudden and violent deaths, fear, anger and confusion. They are both brilliant films that -- like so many others -- show the ugliness of war.
John Goodman and Jeff Bridges in The Big Lebowski |
Little Big Man (1970) Penn and Dances With Wolves (1990) Costner. Two movies about whites being assimilated into Native American tribes as the frontier closes. Dances is a more earnest film and won a passel of awards including the Best Picture Oscar. Oddly it seems the much less respected of the two today and frankly its fall from favor mystifies me. Little Big Man is pure tall tale with Dustin Hoffman starring as an everyman of the old West who meets everyone, is everywhere and does everything. Most notably he is several times adopted as a member of the Cheyennes. In Wolves Kevin Costner is an American soldier who eschews the army and the white world to become a Sioux tribe member. Both films served as rebuttals to the negative portrayals of Native Americans that were such a staple of Hollywood from its beginnings. I wouldn't call either a great film but I've enjoyed repeat looks at both over the years as they are endlessly entertaining in their own rights.
Rebel Without a Cause (1955) Ray and Mean Girls (2004) Waters. I'm proud of this double feature because I thought outside of the box (where exactly is that box?). From the 1950s and 2000s you've got two films about high school students. You could say the similarities end there and not be far wrong. Rebel is meant to be a serious look at teen angst and rebellion while Mean Girls is a comedy about high school cliques, fitting in and the vagaries of teen relationships. I like the idea of having two movies of different eras with different intents that touch upon the same milieu.
No comments:
Post a Comment